Polaris: Chivalric Tragedy at Utmost North‎ Review

This game is really different from most. Some people are even afraid to try it. The setting is awesome, the concept is neat, but there's a glaring difference from tradition RPGs. It's GM-less. I kinda argue that it's not and I'll explain later on. A major downside is it's pretty much 4 players only. It could work with 3 or 5 and probably be very successful that way but it was made with 4 players in mind. Don't have 4 players then you've already got a hurdle to jump over to set this game up.

First off the writing in the book is as if a noble from Polaris wrote it. At least that's my impression. Very artsy and romantic. This could bug some people and I can see where they're coming from but Polaris is a high-class society. I do think this was the author's goal. From that perspective the writing could help set the mood for the setting. Polaris itself was a city "on top of the world", in every meaning of the phrase. At the north pole the people only knew of night. They mapped and named the stars. Wrote stories about them and sang songs in their city made of ice. Then one day the sun comes bringing light and heat, followed by the moon. A series of events happen that make the royal family gets corrupt. They don't know how to react to what's going on. Bad behavior and bad decisions start being made by everyone. Most people are too self-involved to even care. Suddenly a giant pit to hell opens up in the middle of the city called the "mistake" and demons called the "mistaken" come out. Worse just got worser. The only people who care to do anything are the knights.

That's where the players come in. Each play the role of a knight but they take on 3 other roles as well.
Heart- The knight. Traditional PC role.
Mistaken- The demon and antagonist of the heart. Traditional GM role with the exception of NPCs.
Full Moon- Social and Hierarchical characters associated with the heart as well as minor male characters.
New Moon- Personal and emotional characters associated with the heart as well as minor female characters.

These roles rotate with the 4 players around a table. Because of this Polaris is not so much GM-less but that the role of the GM is rotated and shared among the group. 4 different hearts and mistaken and 4 different stories for each. If you wanted something completely different you could be disappointed, if you wanted something traditional in Polaris to recognize this could be a good thing. I think it's a fair median.

Each knight has 4 characteristics and 4 values. The first characteristic is Abilities which is what the knight is trained for or knowledgeable in. Blessings are magical, sacred, or useful items in the knight's inventory. Next is Fate which are significant events and people (not controlled by the Moons) in the knight's past. Last is Office which are titles or social ranks the knight has.

The first value is Ice. Ice is how much compassion the knight has for the world around him when fighting the mistaken to protect others. Light is how well the knight can fight the mistaken on a 1 on 1 basis. Ice and Light start at 1 and improve as the knight progresses. Zeal is the knights drive to save the world. This starts at 4 and goes down as the game progresses. Weariness starts adding up when Zeal reaches 0. This is the knights sorrow and frustration to continue fighting. Each knight will lose. That's another thing that could drive people away from this game. It's not about winning, it's about losing on an epic and poetic scale. It is a "Chivalric Tragedy" after all.

The core mechanic is a bit strange. PCs perform actions by saying key phrases. The heart and the mistaken debate and bargain for what happens next. It's essentially just story telling within the game system. If an aspect is used it gets checked off and must be refreshed to be used again. When a resolution can't be found using just key phrases the die come out. It is rolled. If it's to save others then the result must be lower than Ice to be a success. If it's to save the knight then it must be lower than Light. If higher than the appropriate score then the Knight loses the conflict, but gets an experience roll. The result is compared with Zeal or Weariness. If successful Ice or Light go up a point but Zeal goes down. If the rolled failed then just aspects get refreshed. The more experienced a knight gets the more corrupt they become.

The rest of the book is made up of appendixes. Variant rules, example aspects (highly recommended), examples of playing the game (also highly recommended), and stars. Because the night sky was a major focus to the setting knowing the constellations, stars, and their meanings is very helpful when talking to people, or finding some strange item or symbol.

As I said before this game is fun but not for everyone. It could be useful if a player isn't use to GMing and would like a shot but if more people aren't use to GMing the game could get bogged down. It's interesting and could be a good side-game. There's not a lot of number crunching involved so it has that going for it. The writing and the art are both provocative of the setting. In fact if you get this just for the setting you won't be disappointed. I haven't played this as much as I would like but I'm glad I own it. The game can be purchased here. You can even choose your own price!